Time Required :
Over an hour
Intermediate
Intermediate
You're somewhat experienced with the skills necessary to complete this project, but you haven't mastered all the elements, yet.

sweet sugarbelle™ pie cookies

Celebrate fall with these cute pie inspired cookies!

Step 1

Prepare your roll-out sugar cookie dough following recipe instructions.
TIP: If you would like to use the sugar cookie recipe provided by Sweet Sugarbelle™, click here.

Step 2

Cut out your cookies with a circle cookie cutter. Bake according to recipe and let cool.

Step 3

While, cookies are baking prepare icing following your royal icing recipe instructions.
TIP: If you would like to use the Sweet Sugarbelle™ royal icing recipe, click here.

Step 4

Tint 1/3 of your royal icing orange, 1/3 of your royal icing white with a touch of orange to get the “crust” color, and 1/3 of your frosting white. All of these should be outline consistency (or toothpaste-like).

Step 5

Separate and thin half of your orange royal icing to be flood consistency by adding small amounts of water until you get it to the right consistency. This should be more of a shampoo-like consistency.

Step 6

Prepare four Sweet Sugarbelle™ piping bags and fill them with your different icings.

Step 7

Cut 1/6 of the tip off your orange royal icing and outline the cookie. Allow them to dry for 20-30 minutes before continuing.

Step 8

Grab your bag of flood consistency orange icing and cut 1/6 off the tip. Fill your cookie in, be careful not to overfill, and making sure to stay within the outline you created before. Use the pick tool from the basic tool set to smooth out any inconsistencies if needed. Allow your cookies to dry for 2-4 hours before adding final embellishments.

Step 9

After your base has had time to dry, carefully pipe the pie crust details on the edge of the cookie with the orange/white icing; then carefully add a swirl of white icing in the middle to look like whipped cream. Allow your cookies 5-10 hours to fully dry.

Share your creations with #MakeItWithMichaels

Materials

Product Actions

Product Actions

Materials
 

    Products

  • You’ll Need: 1
    Item # 10051363 
    $15
    $19.99
    clearance
    clearance
    Add to cart options
    *No additional coupons or discounts may be applied. While supplies last. No rain checks.
  • You’ll Need: 1
    Item # 10076247 
    $11.99
    Add to cart options
  • You’ll Need: 1
    Item # 10462740 

    Promotions

    Pricing and Availability May Vary In Stores
    $5
    $12.99
    clearance
    clearance
    Add to cart options
    *No additional coupons or discounts may be applied. While supplies last. No rain checks.
 
Tools

Product Actions

Tools
 

    Products

  • You’ll Need: 1
    Item # 10667673 
    $16.99
    Add to cart options
  • You’ll Need: 1
    Item # 10667679 
    $12.99
    Add to cart options
  • You’ll Need: 1
    Item # 10667683 
    $8.99
    Add to cart options
  • You’ll Need: 1
    Item # 10667696 
    $8.99
    Add to cart options
 

Product Actions

You’ll Also Need
  • Prepared Sugar Cookie Recipe
  • Prepared Royal Icing Recipe
  • Food-Safe Scissors
+ View More